The Lleida Provincial Court heard the trial of the Carreteras case this Friday, a spin-off of the Boreas scandal that has rocked the Catalan public administration. Following eight days of hearings, the prosecution maintained its request for a twelve-year prison sentence for Jordi Benet, the former head of the Generalitat’s Roads Department in Lleida, and upheld the penalties sought for the other four defendants. The only amendment concerned Baltasar Rullán, the former head of Maintenance, who is now also charged with the offence of fraudulent mismanagement; this has increased the prosecution’s demand for him to eight years in prison and twelve years of disqualification from public office. The case has been reserved for judgment, yet the account presented in the courtroom leaves uncomfortable questions about how public funds were managed in a strategically important region such as Lleida.
A web of favours, payments and irregularities
The prosecution’s case is unequivocal: for years, the relationship between Jordi Benet and the executives of MJ Grúas far exceeded professional boundaries. According to the public prosecutor, the former Roads chief allegedly received cash, gifts, Christmas hampers, meals and free labour on his estate in exchange for favouring the company in public works contracts and certifications. In the prosecution’s view, this was not merely a cordial rapport between civil servants and contractors, but a system of reciprocal benefits that diverted millions of euros from funds earmarked for the maintenance of roads in Lleida.
To underpin this thesis, the prosecutor has urged the judges to adopt a bird’s-eye view of the case. In other words, rather than assessing each conversation, payment or certification in isolation, they should examine the whole picture: the intercepted calls, the accounting records, the police reports and the witness statements. Only in this way, according to the prosecution, does it become clear that the relationship between Benet and MJ Grúas did not conform to the norms of public procurement.
The C-12: information prior to official authorisation
One of the most striking episodes in the trial centres on the works on the C-12 road between Lleida and Corbins in 2016. According to the prosecution’s interpretation of the intercepted telephone conversations, MJ Grúas was aware, before the official authorisation was granted, that the suspension of the works would be lifted. This insider information allegedly allowed the company to bring forward the resumption of the works and expedite the certifications and payments, all with the complicity of the then head of the Road Department.
The conversation of 21 July 2016 occupies a central place in the prosecution’s narrative. In it, the late Josep Maria Grúas Estadella told his son that those euros had to be paid to Jordi. The prosecution interprets this phrase as a direct reference to a payment to Jordi Benet. The defendants, for their part, maintain that it was a financial aid to a relative of the businessman who also happens to be called Jordi. This is one of the keys to the trial: if the judges believe that the Jordi mentioned in the conversation is the former head of the Road Department, the bribery charge gains ground. If not, a significant part of the prosecution’s case is undermined.
The prosecution has also highlighted another conversation in which the parties discussed handing an envelope to the former head of the Roads Department. Benet denied on Thursday having received any money, asserting that the envelope contained outstanding documentation. The prosecutor, however, challenged this account, linking those conversations to MJ Grúas’s interest in resuming work swiftly and securing payment.
The Ponts contract: favourable scoring and €5,000 in cash
Another contentious issue in the trial is the road maintenance contract for the Ponts area. According to the prosecution, Jordi Benet was responsible for the technical assessment of the tender and awarded MJ Grúas 33 points, five more than its main competitors. The Crown Prosecution Service argues that this scoring cannot be explained solely by the company’s technical merits, but rather by the personal relationship Benet maintained with the firm’s executives.
The most damning detail in this section is a withdrawal of €5,000 from the company’s cash box, recorded the day after the contract was signed, on 5 November 2014. The entry identifies the funds as belonging to “J. Bebet” and is signed by two senior figures at the construction company. The prosecution maintains that this money was intended for Jordi Benet. The defendants have denied this.
Certifications: €860,000 for unexecuted work
Regarding the certifications under the Ponts maintenance contract, the prosecution has estimated that the difference between the work actually carried out and the work certified by December 2016 amounted to approximately €860,000. For the prosecution, this demonstrates that payment was made for work that was never executed, a practice it describes as fraudulent mismanagement.
The defence and the accused contend, conversely, that the certificates represented advance payments and could encompass work yet to be carried out. Baltasar Rullán went so far as to assert that this system of prepayments was standard practice. The prosecution rebuts this account, pointing out that the system failed to provide any mechanism for verifying which tasks had been completed and which had not, thereby opening the door to payments for non-existent services. Consequently, Rullán is now also charged with fraudulent mismanagement, a charge that carries an additional four-year prison sentence on top of the continuing falsification of public documents already attributed to him.
Weddings, land and €94,300 in cash
Beyond the construction works and the certificates, the prosecution has laid out a list of payments and gifts which, in its view, completes the portrait of a corrupt relationship. These include meals, presents and free labour on a property owned by the former head of the Roads Department, as well as €12,000 transferred from the company to fund the weddings of his two children, €6,000 for each event.
The prosecution also highlighted cash deposits totalling approximately €94,300 detected in Benet’s account between 2011 and 2016, which the accused attributed to rent from properties that, he claimed, he always collected in cash. It further cited €20,000 found in a safe deposit box registered in his daughter’s name, which his wife explained was derived from a family inheritance. Individually, these details may have alternative explanations, but the prosecution presents them as pieces of a jigsaw puzzle pointing in a single direction.
The defence: a family dispute, not an institutional scheme
The defence has advanced an alternative narrative: that no payments were made to Benet, and that the accusations stem from disputes between the family branches that controlled the construction firm. The former head of the Roads Department’s lawyer argued that the intent to commit the alleged crimes has not been proven, emphasising that the prosecution’s case rests on circumstantial evidence. He also pointed out contradictions in the Fiscalía’s account of the works on the C-12 and Ponts projects.
The private prosecution, representing the 40 per cent shareholder that reported the irregularities, has aligned itself with the Fiscalía’s position. It rejected the notion that the case is merely a family dispute, highlighting that the complaints filed by the dissenting partners were corroborated during the investigation and trial. In its final submissions, it dropped the charge of membership of a criminal group, but maintained the charges of abuse of influence and active bribery against the two executives.
The sentences sought by the Fiscalía
The sentencing requests are severe. Jordi Benet faces twelve years’ imprisonment and 37 years’ disqualification from public office for passive bribery, disloyal management fraud, administrative malpractice, and continuous falsification of a public document. For the executives Josep Maria Grúas Pauls and Miguel Turmo, the Fiscalía is seeking twelve years’ imprisonment, a fine of one million euros, and a twenty-year ban on contracting with the public sector for each.
For Baltasar Rullán, the request is now eight years’ imprisonment and twelve years’ disqualification, plus a fine of €10,800. For Mari Pau Benet, the former head of the Roads Department’s daughter, the Fiscalía is seeking four years’ imprisonment and a fine of €60,000 for money laundering.
What is at stake for Lleida
Beyond the individual sentences, the Carreteras case raises a question that concerns the entire population of Lleida: how are public contracts controlled in the province? The prosecution describes a system in which a single civil servant allegedly steered competitive tenders, expedited payments and certified work that had not been carried out, over a period of years. If the verdict confirms this thesis, it will not merely result in the conviction of five individuals, but will paint a portrait of an administration vulnerable to capture by private interests.
For the citizens of Lleida, the case has concrete consequences. Funds earmarked for the maintenance of the roads they use daily allegedly ended up, in part, funding meals, gifts and unjustified payments. Public trust in the management of public affairs is damaged, and the perception that those who administer the public purse do not always answer to the public gains ground. In a context of fiscal austerity and limited public resources, cases of this kind feed political apathy and discontent with the institutions.
The verdict, when it comes, will be a landmark. But the trial has already made it clear that Lleida cannot assume that corruption in public administration is a problem confined to other places or other times. The Carreteras case demonstrates that transparency, oversight and accountability are not administrative formalities, but necessary barriers to protect the public’s money and trust.
Sources consulted
Written and corrected with the help of artificial intelligence from the sources cited. Before publication, an automated check verifies figures, quotes and allegations. If you spot an error, write to us.
Spotted an error in this story? Tell us: corrections policy and newsroom contact.
← Back to news
Comments
Comments are moderated by the editorial team: they are published after review.